Records since the 1969 season.
| Matchup | Record | Win % | Vs Expected | Games |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mets Phillies | 498-482-4 | 50.8% | +5.7 | 925 |
| Mets Nationals | 489-480-6 | 50.5% | -14.5 | 912 |
| Mets Braves | 395-443-3 | 47.1% | -9.5 | 795 |
| Mets Cardinals | 341-337 | 50.3% | +10.2 | 635 |
| Mets Pirates | 340-320-5 | 51.5% | +5.9 | 624 |
| Mets Cubs | 328-335-1 | 49.5% | -11.2 | 622 |
| Mets Dodgers | 262-290 | 47.5% | +4.0 | 536 |
| Mets Marlins | 295-254-3 | 53.7% | +2.5 | 532 |
| Mets Padres | 264-269-3 | 49.5% | -20.1 | 511 |
| Mets Giants | 265-268-3 | 49.7% | -0.8 | 510 |
| Mets Reds | 264-266 | 49.8% | +6.2 | 509 |
| Mets Astros | 220-247-3 | 47.1% | -13.8 | 452 |
| Mets Rockies | 130-113 | 53.5% | +0.7 | 227 |
| Mets Diamondbacks | 106-89 | 54.4% | +5.8 | 187 |
| Mets Brewers | 91-93-3 | 49.5% | -5.1 | 176 |
| Mets Yankees | 72-88-3 | 45.0% | +2.2 | 155 |
| Mets Orioles | 35-23-3 | 60.3% | +3.4 | 58 |
| Mets Red Sox | 23-31 | 42.6% | -3.2 | 52 |
| Mets Blue Jays | 28-19 | 59.6% | +4.5 | 45 |
| Mets Rays | 16-23-3 | 41.0% | -4.9 | 40 |
| Mets Athletics | 21-17 | 55.3% | +1.5 | 36 |
| Mets Tigers | 17-19 | 47.2% | -1.6 | 32 |
| Mets Twins | 20-14 | 58.8% | +2.5 | 32 |
| Mets Angels | 18-15 | 54.5% | +1.6 | 31 |
| Mets Royals | 16-17 | 48.5% | -1.6 | 31 |
| Mets Rangers | 16-12-3 | 57.1% | +0.5 | 28 |
| Mets Guardians | 16-11-3 | 59.3% | +1.5 | 27 |
| Mets Mariners | 11-19 | 36.7% | -3.2 | 27 |
| Mets White Sox | 14-8-3 | 63.6% | +0.1 | 23 |
Swipe sideways to see all columns