@ Dolphins
25-13
@ Colts
23-17
Playoffs
2-0
VS EXPECTED
Dolphins -0.6
Avg Points
22.0-17.5
Most Recent Winner
Colts 8-33
Head-To-Head Margin (Max Last 150 Matches)
| Date | Matchup | Result | Winner | Model Projection | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2025 | 8–33 | Indianapolis Colts +25 | Indianapolis Colts +1.5 | Regular | |
| Oct 20, 2024 | 10–16 | Indianapolis Colts +6 | Indianapolis Colts +2.7 | Regular | |
| Oct 3, 2021 | 27–17 | Indianapolis Colts +10 | Miami Dolphins +2.5 | Regular | |
| Nov 10, 2019 | 16–12 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Indianapolis Colts +11.5 | Regular | |
| Nov 25, 2018 | 24–27 | Indianapolis Colts +3 | Indianapolis Colts +4.8 | Regular | |
| Dec 27, 2015 | 18–12 | Indianapolis Colts +6 | Indianapolis Colts +0.3 | Regular | |
| Sep 15, 2013 | 24–20 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Indianapolis Colts +3.7 | Regular | |
| Nov 4, 2012 | 20–23 | Indianapolis Colts +3 | Miami Dolphins +1.7 | Regular | |
| Sep 21, 2009 | 27–23 | Indianapolis Colts +4 | Indianapolis Colts +4.3 | Regular | |
| Dec 31, 2006 | 22–27 | Indianapolis Colts +5 | Indianapolis Colts +10.1 | Regular | |
| Nov 2, 2003 | 23–17 | Indianapolis Colts +6 | Miami Dolphins +3.9 | Regular | |
| Sep 15, 2002 | 21–13 | Miami Dolphins +8 | Indianapolis Colts +1.9 | Regular | |
| Dec 10, 2001 | 6–41 | Miami Dolphins +35 | Miami Dolphins +8.0 | Regular | |
| Nov 11, 2001 | 27–24 | Miami Dolphins +3 | Indianapolis Colts +2.1 | Regular | |
| Dec 30, 2000 | 17–23 | Miami Dolphins +6 | Miami Dolphins +2.5 | Playoffs | |
| Dec 17, 2000 | 20–13 | Indianapolis Colts +7 | Miami Dolphins +3.5 | Regular | |
| Nov 26, 2000 | 17–14 | Miami Dolphins +3 | Indianapolis Colts +2.9 | Regular | |
| Dec 5, 1999 | 37–34 | Indianapolis Colts +3 | Miami Dolphins +4.6 | Regular | |
| Oct 10, 1999 | 34–31 | Miami Dolphins +3 | Miami Dolphins +4.4 | Regular | |
| Nov 8, 1998 | 14–27 | Miami Dolphins +13 | Miami Dolphins +10.2 | Regular | |
| Sep 6, 1998 | 24–15 | Miami Dolphins +9 | Miami Dolphins +0.3 | Regular | |
| Dec 14, 1997 | 0–41 | Indianapolis Colts +41 | Miami Dolphins +5.2 | Regular | |
| Aug 31, 1997 | 10–16 | Miami Dolphins +6 | Miami Dolphins +3.3 | Regular | |
| Nov 10, 1996 | 13–37 | Miami Dolphins +24 | Miami Dolphins +4.5 | Regular | |
| Sep 23, 1996 | 6–10 | Indianapolis Colts +4 | Indianapolis Colts +2.6 | Regular | |
| Nov 26, 1995 | 28–36 | Indianapolis Colts +8 | Miami Dolphins +0.9 | Regular | |
| Oct 8, 1995 | 27–24 | Indianapolis Colts +3 | Miami Dolphins +10.3 | Regular | |
| Dec 18, 1994 | 6–10 | Indianapolis Colts +4 | Miami Dolphins +4.1 | Regular | |
| Nov 6, 1994 | 21–22 | Miami Dolphins +1 | Miami Dolphins +10.6 | Regular | |
| Oct 24, 1993 | 27–41 | Miami Dolphins +14 | Miami Dolphins +9.8 | Regular | |
| Sep 5, 1993 | 24–20 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Miami Dolphins +2.4 | Regular | |
| Nov 8, 1992 | 28–0 | Miami Dolphins +28 | Miami Dolphins +4.2 | Regular | |
| Oct 25, 1992 | 31–20 | Indianapolis Colts +11 | Miami Dolphins +13.3 | Regular | |
| Nov 3, 1991 | 10–6 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Miami Dolphins +4.3 | Regular | |
| Sep 8, 1991 | 6–17 | Miami Dolphins +11 | Miami Dolphins +7.3 | Regular | |
| Dec 30, 1990 | 17–23 | Miami Dolphins +6 | Miami Dolphins +6.8 | Regular | |
| Oct 28, 1990 | 27–7 | Miami Dolphins +20 | Miami Dolphins +0.3 | Regular | |
| Dec 17, 1989 | 13–42 | Indianapolis Colts +29 | Indianapolis Colts +3.5 | Regular | |
| Nov 5, 1989 | 13–19 | Miami Dolphins +6 | Indianapolis Colts +0.1 | Regular | |
| Dec 4, 1988 | 31–28 | Indianapolis Colts +3 | Indianapolis Colts +0.3 | Regular | |
| Sep 25, 1988 | 13–15 | Indianapolis Colts +2 | Indianapolis Colts +1.7 | Regular | |
| Nov 15, 1987 | 40–21 | Indianapolis Colts +19 | Miami Dolphins +8.2 | Regular | |
| Sep 20, 1987 | 23–10 | Miami Dolphins +13 | Miami Dolphins +4.1 | Regular | |
| Oct 26, 1986 | 17–13 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Miami Dolphins +6.4 | Regular | |
| Sep 14, 1986 | 10–30 | Miami Dolphins +20 | Miami Dolphins +10.8 | Regular | |
| Nov 17, 1985 | 34–20 | Miami Dolphins +14 | Miami Dolphins +7.4 | Regular | |
| Sep 15, 1985 | 13–30 | Miami Dolphins +17 | Miami Dolphins +14.5 | Regular | |
| Dec 9, 1984 | 35–17 | Miami Dolphins +18 | Miami Dolphins +8.5 | Regular | |
| Sep 23, 1984 | 7–44 | Miami Dolphins +37 | Miami Dolphins +13.8 | Regular | |
| Nov 20, 1983 | 0–37 | Miami Dolphins +37 | Miami Dolphins +13.1 | Regular | |
| Oct 23, 1983 | 21–7 | Miami Dolphins +14 | Miami Dolphins +6.7 | Regular | |
| Jan 2, 1983 | 34–7 | Miami Dolphins +27 | Miami Dolphins +9.4 | Regular | |
| Sep 19, 1982 | 20–24 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Miami Dolphins +14.1 | Regular | |
| Nov 1, 1981 | 10–27 | Miami Dolphins +17 | Miami Dolphins +11.5 | Regular | |
| Sep 27, 1981 | 31–28 | Miami Dolphins +3 | Miami Dolphins +4.4 | Regular | |
| Dec 14, 1980 | 24–14 | Miami Dolphins +10 | Indianapolis Colts +1.5 | Regular | |
| Oct 5, 1980 | 30–17 | Indianapolis Colts +13 | Miami Dolphins +8.0 | Regular | |
| Nov 25, 1979 | 28–24 | Miami Dolphins +4 | Miami Dolphins +4.2 | Regular | |
| Nov 11, 1979 | 0–19 | Miami Dolphins +19 | Miami Dolphins +9.9 | Regular | |
| Oct 29, 1978 | 8–26 | Miami Dolphins +18 | Miami Dolphins +7.6 | Regular | |
| Sep 10, 1978 | 42–0 | Miami Dolphins +42 | Indianapolis Colts +2.7 | Regular | |
| Dec 5, 1977 | 6–17 | Miami Dolphins +11 | Miami Dolphins +2.7 | Regular | |
| Oct 9, 1977 | 28–45 | Indianapolis Colts +17 | Indianapolis Colts +4.6 | Regular | |
| Nov 22, 1976 | 17–16 | Indianapolis Colts +1 | Miami Dolphins +2.0 | Regular | |
| Oct 10, 1976 | 14–28 | Indianapolis Colts +14 | Indianapolis Colts +2.0 | Regular | |
| Dec 14, 1975 | 7–10 | Indianapolis Colts +3 | Miami Dolphins +3.6 | Regular | |
| Nov 23, 1975 | 33–17 | Indianapolis Colts +16 | Miami Dolphins +13.2 | Regular | |
| Dec 8, 1974 | 17–16 | Miami Dolphins +1 | Miami Dolphins +9.9 | Regular | |
| Oct 27, 1974 | 7–17 | Miami Dolphins +10 | Miami Dolphins +16.6 | Regular | |
| Dec 9, 1973 | 3–16 | Indianapolis Colts +13 | Miami Dolphins +12.5 | Regular | |
| Nov 11, 1973 | 0–44 | Miami Dolphins +44 | Miami Dolphins +16.6 | Regular | |
| Dec 16, 1972 | 0–16 | Miami Dolphins +16 | Miami Dolphins +10.9 | Regular | |
| Oct 29, 1972 | 23–0 | Miami Dolphins +23 | Miami Dolphins +2.3 | Regular | |
| Jan 2, 1972 | 0–21 | Miami Dolphins +21 | Indianapolis Colts +0.2 | Playoffs | |
| Dec 11, 1971 | 3–14 | Indianapolis Colts +11 | Indianapolis Colts +5.0 | Regular | |
| Nov 21, 1971 | 14–17 | Miami Dolphins +3 | Miami Dolphins +2.0 | Regular | |
| Nov 22, 1970 | 17–34 | Miami Dolphins +17 | Indianapolis Colts +0.3 | Regular | |
| Nov 1, 1970 | 0–35 | Indianapolis Colts +35 | Indianapolis Colts +4.5 | Regular |