Records since the 1969 season.
| Matchup | Record | Win % | Vs Expected | Games |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yankees Red Sox | 473-450-4 | 51.2% | -8.0 | 886 |
| Yankees Orioles | 517-387-8 | 57.2% | +13.8 | 861 |
| Yankees Blue Jays | 408-341-6 | 54.5% | -14.3 | 728 |
| Yankees Guardians | 387-258 | 60.0% | +28.4 | 596 |
| Yankees Tigers | 344-281 | 55.0% | -2.9 | 593 |
| Yankees Angels | 305-266-3 | 53.4% | -10.7 | 556 |
| Yankees Athletics | 309-263 | 54.0% | +3.1 | 556 |
| Yankees Rangers | 330-252 | 56.7% | +2.8 | 554 |
| Yankees Royals | 343-215-1 | 61.5% | +30.0 | 540 |
| Yankees Twins | 338-204-3 | 62.4% | +34.1 | 524 |
| Yankees White Sox | 300-232-1 | 56.4% | +2.7 | 509 |
| Yankees Rays | 277-213-4 | 56.5% | -8.0 | 473 |
| Yankees Mariners | 277-201-3 | 57.9% | +0.6 | 473 |
| Yankees Brewers | 223-196-1 | 53.2% | -6.3 | 395 |
| Yankees Mets | 88-72-3 | 55.0% | -5.2 | 155 |
| Yankees Astros | 59-50-3 | 54.1% | -0.1 | 105 |
| Yankees Braves | 37-24-3 | 60.7% | +3.3 | 61 |
| Yankees Phillies | 31-25 | 55.4% | -1.4 | 54 |
| Yankees Dodgers | 24-27 | 47.1% | -1.7 | 48 |
| Yankees Marlins | 26-26 | 50.0% | -5.1 | 48 |
| Yankees Nationals | 29-21 | 58.0% | -0.8 | 48 |
| Yankees Diamondbacks | 21-17-3 | 55.3% | -2.0 | 39 |
| Yankees Reds | 17-21 | 44.7% | -5.2 | 35 |
| Yankees Rockies | 17-14-3 | 54.8% | -4.3 | 32 |
| Yankees Padres | 21-10-3 | 67.7% | +1.4 | 32 |
| Yankees Cubs | 21-10 | 67.7% | +3.4 | 28 |
| Yankees Pirates | 20-11 | 64.5% | +1.2 | 28 |
| Yankees Giants | 19-8 | 70.4% | +3.8 | 25 |
| Yankees Cardinals | 14-11-2 | 56.0% | -0.3 | 24 |
Swipe sideways to see all columns