| Date | Matchup | Result | Winner | Model Projection | Stage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 1996 | 2–1 | Blackhawks +1 | Flames +0.0 | ||
| Apr 23, 1996 | 6–1 | Red Wings +5 | Red Wings +1.1 | ||
| Apr 23, 1996 | 4–3 | Rangers +1 | Canadiens +0.4 | ||
| Apr 23, 1996 | 4–1 | Flyers +3 | Lightning +0.0 | ||
| Apr 23, 1996 | 1–5 | Blues +4 | Blues +0.6 |